Friday, November 20, 2026

The Aesthetics of Darkness: Art, Defense Mechanisms, and Emotional Maturity

9 minreading time

A person can make the darker aspects of their inner world visible with extraordinary creativity. They can give form to their pain, turn their fears into characters, and convey a sense of fragmentation through images. But does any of this mean that the person has truly confronted their own wounds?

Art can sometimes be a way of reaching experiences that words cannot. Yet being able to express an emotion is not the same as fully understanding it or integrating it into everyday life.

An important question thus arises from the perspective of the psychology of art: Is artistic creativity a space of transformation in which a person can encounter themselves, or can it also be a form of defense that enables them to continue living with conflicts they have not yet faced?

These two possibilities need not be mutually exclusive.

1. Grotesque Bodies: The Artistic Language of Darkness

In horror art, body horror, and grotesque aesthetics, the familiar boundaries of bodies are often disrupted. Fragmented anatomies, organs merging into one another, exaggerated musculature, armor-clad bodies, and solitary creatures may both disturb and fascinate the viewer.

Julia Kristeva’s (1980/1982) concept of abjection offers an important theoretical framework for understanding the complex response to things that threaten the boundaries of the body and identity. Disgust and attraction, the urge to withdraw and curiosity, can coexist within the same experience.

This is where the power of grotesque art lies: by disrupting conventional ideas of wholeness, it makes other forms of existence imaginable.

However, creating dark works does not indicate that an artist is traumatized or psychologically unintegrated. Artistic traditions, technical possibilities, and the freedom of fiction are meaningful in their own right.

Even so, recurring images may open up a space for subjective inquiry for the person creating them. Why is strength repeatedly represented through armor and sharp weapons? Why does closeness sometimes appear as merging (interpenetration) or fragmentation? What kind of life might be possible after destruction?

These questions are not intended to diagnose the artist from the outside, but to reflect on the possibilities of meaning that art may open up.

2. Sublimation: Does Turning Pain into Art Mean Healing?

In psychodynamic theory, sublimation refers to a person’s ability to channel conflicting impulses and emotions into creative or socially constructive activities.

George Vaillant (2011) places sublimation and humor among the more mature defense mechanisms. Defenses are not merely ways of distancing oneself from reality; they may also be adaptive processes that help a person withstand intense emotions.

In this respect, art can be an immensely valuable resource for living.

Stuckey and Nobel’s (2010) review identifies associations between creative activities and various health and well-being outcomes. A more recent meta-analysis also reported that structured art therapy interventions show promise in reducing depressive symptoms, while noting methodological limitations in the research (Qiao et al., 2026).

Nevertheless, personal artistic practice and art therapy conducted by a professional are not the same process.

A person may transform their pain through art while continuing to repeat certain patterns of behavior associated with that pain.

Art can make a wound easier to carry; this does not mean that all its effects have disappeared.

Perhaps the central issue, then, is not whether art can be healing, but whether healing can be understood as something limited to creative production alone.

3. Can Life Become Narrower Even as Artistic Production Continues?

A person’s continued productivity in a particular field does not mean that they retain the same vitality in every area of life.

A person may continue painting, writing, or designing beasts while withdrawing from other activities they once found pleasurable. Music, movement, friendship, curiosity, and everyday participation may gradually diminish.

In psychological literature, anhedonia is a concept associated with a reduction in the pleasure derived from activities that were previously enjoyable. However, giving up an activity or preferring solitude is not, in itself, an indication of psychopathology.

What matters is what the change means to the person, how it affects their quality of life, and whether it occurs alongside other symptoms.

Here we can question the role of creative production: Does art broaden a person’s connection to life, or does it become one of the few areas in which they can continue to function as their life grows increasingly restricted?

Even in the latter case, the value of art is not diminished. On the contrary, it may serve as an important protective resource.

Yet the continuation of creative work does not mean that support is unnecessary in other areas. Sometimes a person survives through art.

Later, to participate in life again, they may also need other relationships, experiences, or professional support.

4. Freedom in Art, Defensiveness in Relationships

An artist may transcend social norms, bodily categories, and conventional understandings of identity in their work. Even so, they may not be entirely free from familiar patterns of power, status, and approval in everyday relationships.

Connell and Messerschmidt’s (2005) discussion of hegemonic “masculinity” offers a theoretical framework for understanding how power and status are structured within social relations.

Although this approach does not directly explain individual behaviors, it can help us consider social approval, visibility, and power relations in their broader social context.

From this perspective, it is worth considering why someone who creates unconventional forms in art might seek the security offered by familiar roles in social settings. Humor, efforts to appear strong, or seeking others’ approval can, in some circumstances, feel easier than expressing vulnerability directly.

Of course, neither humor nor a desire for visibility is, in itself, a psychological problem. What matters is how these behaviors relate to the person’s needs and their effects on others.

A distinction between two different capacities becomes clear here: being seen and being able to see.

Wanting our own complexity to be understood does not mean that we are also able to understand the complexity of the person before us.

Artistic freedom can be an important domain for expressing emotional freedom. But in actual relationships, the counterpart to this freedom is the ability to recognize the autonomy and vulnerability of other beings as well.

5. Being Wounded, Causing Harm, and Taking Responsibility

A person may sometimes carry traces of past difficulties into new relationships without being aware of it. Intense fears, expectations of rejection, shame, or a need for self-protection may accompany behaviors such as withdrawing, becoming defensive, testing the other person, or cutting off communication.

This highlights the importance of trying to understand harmful behaviors. But understanding is not the same as excusing.

Tangney, Stuewig, and Mashek (2007) examine how shame and guilt relate differently to ethical behavior. Whereas shame may involve a negative evaluation of the self as a whole, guilt may focus more on a particular behavior and create a basis for wanting to make amends.

This distinction is valuable in relation to emotional maturation.

Seeing oneself as entirely bad or inadequate can sometimes make it harder to take the steps necessary for change. By contrast, recognizing the effects of one’s behavior, taking responsibility, and seeking ways to make amends when necessary can open the way to a new relationship.

Kristin Neff’s (2003) approach to self-compassion also emphasizes the ability to acknowledge one’s pain without denying it or condemning oneself in a destructive way.

Compassion and responsibility are not opposites.

Seeing another person’s wounds does not require us to abandon our own boundaries. Likewise, having caused harm in the past does not condemn a person to repeat those behaviors forever.

The possibility of change grows stronger when a person can recognize both their own pain and the effects of their behavior on others.

6. Genuine Transformation: From Knowing Oneself to Living Differently

Emotional maturity does not mean never experiencing difficult emotions again. A person may become angry, afraid, jealous, or feel rejected. What matters is how they are able to act when these emotions arise.

James Gross’s (1998) model of emotion regulation explains that the processes that generate and sustain emotional experience can be addressed at different stages. The mentalization approach developed by Fonagy and colleagues (2002), meanwhile, emphasizes the capacity to understand one’s own behavior and that of others through mental states.

Considered together, these two approaches suggest an understanding of maturation that goes beyond recognizing emotion: a person becomes aware of what they are feeling, tries to make sense of it, takes the other person’s experience into account, and can choose how to act differently.

Kashdan and Rottenberg’s (2010) discussion of psychological flexibility also emphasizes the importance of adapting to changing circumstances and adjusting behavior according to context for psychological health.

This process becomes particularly visible in relationships.

A person may desire closeness without having to predetermine the form it will take. Love does not necessarily have to turn into a romantic partnership, physical intimacy, or a socially recognized relationship model. It may do so, too.

At the same time, free exploration requires mutual openness, consent, boundaries, and care. An encounter between two distinct beings is not about losing themselves in each other, but about creating a shared experience while preserving their own integrity.

Art can make a person’s own shadow visible. Encountering another person, in turn, can help them recognize how that shadow moves within relationships.

Sometimes these encounters are painful. We confront our own defenses, the harm we have caused in the past, or the needs we have been unable to meet. Yet this awareness can also mark the beginning of developing different ways of acting.

Seeking psychological support when needed, reassessing old ways of coping, and reconnecting with areas of life from which we have previously withdrawn are also parts of this process.

Perhaps genuine transformation is not simply about finding more compelling ways to tell the stories of our wounds. It is about learning to live with an awareness of them, without passing them on to others.

Art can kindle a light in the darkness. Emotional maturation is the process of learning what to do with what we see in that light.

Kaynakça

  • Connell, R. W., & Messerschmidt, J. W. (2005). Hegemonic masculinity: Rethinking the concept. Gender & Society, 19(6), 829–859. https://doi.org/10.1177/0891243205278639
  • Fonagy, P., Gergely, G., Jurist, E. L., & Target, M. (2002). Affect Regulation, Mentalization, and the Development of the Self. Other Press.
  • Gross, J. J. (1998). The emerging field of emotion regulation: An integrative review. Review of General Psychology, 2(3), 271–299. https://doi.org/10.1037/1089-2680.2.3.271
  • Kashdan, T. B., & Rottenberg, J. (2010). Psychological flexibility as a fundamental aspect of health. Clinical Psychology Review, 30(7), 865–878. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2010.03.001
  • Kristeva, J. (1982). Powers of horror: An essay on abjection (L. S. Roudiez, Trans.). Columbia University Press. (Original work published 1980)
  • Neff, K. D. (2003). Self-compassion: An alternative conceptualization of a healthy attitude toward oneself. Self and Identity, 2(2), 85–101. https://doi.org/10.1080/15298860309032
  • Qiao, L., Zhu, B., Liu, P., & Chen, X. (2026). The effectiveness of art therapy on adults with depression: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 33(3), 545–560. https://doi.org/10.1111/jpm.70127
  • Stuckey, H. L., & Nobel, J. (2010). The connection between art, healing, and public health: A review of current literature. American Journal of Public Health, 100(2), 254–263. https://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.2008.156497
  • Tangney, J. P., Stuewig, J., & Mashek, D. J. (2007). Moral emotions and moral behavior. Annual Review of Psychology, 58, 345–372. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.psych.56.091103.070145
  • Vaillant, G. E. (2011). Involuntary coping mechanisms: A psychodynamic perspective. Dialogues in Clinical Neuroscience, 13(3), 366–370. https://doi.org/10.31887/DCNS.2011.13.2/gvaillant
Ejder Atlas Akmaner Ejder Atlas Akmaner
Ejder Atlas Akmaner is an interdisciplinary writer, Logotherapist and Existential Analyst, as well as a Somatic Meaning Guide. Akmaner holds two undergraduate degrees, in Archaeology and Philosophy, and completed a thesis-based postgraduate degree in Comparative Literature. Akmaner also holds an associate degree in Marketing and chose to leave an associate degree programme in Laboratory and Veterinary Health on ethical grounds. In addition, Akmaner has completed certified training in psychology and related fields through a range of international institutions and universities, as well as advanced training in Logotherapy and Existential Analysis accredited by the Viktor Frankl Institute. Drawing on diverse fields of science and art, Akmaner developed the Somatic Meaning Guidance approach, which explores meaning across mental, bodily and relational dimensions. While grounded primarily in Logotherapy and Existential Analysis, the approach also draws on somatic practices including fascia-sensitive yoga, mindfulness and breathwork. Somatic Meaning Guidance understands established patterns of thought, behaviour and relating not as fixed structures, but as processes that can be reshaped through awareness, experience and new learning. Scientific findings on neuroplasticity and the nervous system’s capacity for experience- and learning-dependent change provide one of the scientific foundations for this understanding of transformation. Akmaner carries out this work under the independent brand Ejderhane. Akmaner is also a Dynamic Ving Tshun practitioner. Direct embodied experience within this discipline — including contact, distance, centre, orientation, balance, boundaries and response — is incorporated into training and explored through the perspective of Somatic Meaning Guidance. In writing and creative practice, Akmaner uses worldbuilding, myth, narrative, symbolic systems and poetic expression as tools for exploring psychological and existential meaning. Through different narrative and conceptual models, Akmaner examines identity, relationships, values, culture, transformation and the search for meaning. Akmaner also develops public-facing work through the Atlas of Meaning and İletişim Çıkmazları (Communication Impasses) series, as well as the podcast series Bedenin Bildiği Anlam (The Meaning the Body Knows). Across these projects, Akmaner explores how language, historical concepts, social categories, boundaries, interpersonal patterns and embodied experience shape the lives of sentient beings, while also examining the possibilities for change that can emerge within these patterns. Through an academic connection with the University of Iceland, Akmaner remains open to developing this interdisciplinary work within an international academic setting. Alongside independent fieldwork, training, creative practice and applied work, Akmaner also writes for Psychology Times.