Photographs hidden for years in a basement… a cold-eyed person holding a small memory in their hand or dark fantasies accumulated over years behind an ordinary looking face. The stories of serial killers are not just material for horror movies; they are echoes of a truth hidden in the darkest labyrinths of our minds. But how can the innocent laughter echoing in a child’s room one day turn into a crime scene filled with silent screams? What makes the same hands that once held toys later reach for knives soaked in blood?
Seeds of Childhood Trauma
This is where fantasies come into play. The way out of traumatic childhood experiences becomes the creation of an “alternative reality” in the mind. However, these fantasies are not innocent. They are built on power, domination, and violence—like a mental stage where the rehearsal of murder is performed (Douglas & Olshaker, 1995).
Serial killers, just like a painter hitting the canvas with a brush, repaint their mental images over and over again. It starts in thought: choosing the victim, controlling them, the details of torture. Then these mental scenarios begin to guide decision-making processes. Cognitive psychology defines this as the distortion of memory and decision-making mechanisms.
The signs John Douglas calls the “homicidal triad” – animal torture, bed-wetting, fire setting – are the early harbingers of these fantasies (Time, 2017). These childhood behaviors signal that the brain’s empathy circuits are not developing in a healthy way.
The Cold Anatomy of the Brain
fMRI studies have revealed striking differences in the brains of serial killers. It has been found that gray matter volume in the prefrontal cortex is 11% lower (Raine, 2013), while the amygdala shows weak responses in threat and emotional processing. According to Dr. Kent Kiehl’s research, the paralimbic systems of these individuals show very low levels of activity in emotion and moral evaluation (New Yorker, 2008).
Most serial killers exhibit traits of psychopathy and antisocial personality disorder. Superficial charm, manipulation, lack of remorse—all are evidence of this. But the most important factor is cognitive distortions. Instead of empathy, they have instrumental thinking; instead of emotion, reward–punishment calculation; instead of perceiving people as humans, they see them as objects. Understanding this mental structure also explains why murders are committed with such cold-blooded planning.
What Did It Mean to Them?
Behind Ted Bundy’s charismatic looks was the effort to compensate for childhood abandonment traumas with violent fantasies. Jeffrey Dahmer, on the other hand, not only killed his victims but also experienced the illusion of “eternal possession” by exercising control over them. In both cases, we see that for them, murder was not an ordinary act but a bloody reflection of fragmented cognitive schemas.
The Power of Understanding Darkness
To understand a serial killer is not to excuse them. But scientifically, it is clear: serial killers are born at the intersection of biological predispositions, early-life traumas, and cognitive psychology distortions.
Cognitive psychology tells us this: their world operates with codes very different from those we perceive. Lack of empathy, fantasy overpowering reality, systematic distortions of decision-making… All of these are the dark components that transform an ordinary person into a “serial killer.” What is truly chilling is this: they are proof of how fragile and malleable the human mind really is.
Empathy Deficit & Impulse Control Disorder: Dysfunction in the frontal lobe–amygdala axis forms the neurobiological basis of lack of empathy, impulsive and perverse behaviors.
Cognitive & Neurobiological explanation: Prefrontal and amygdala dysfunction.
Fantasy and Reality Spiral: The way to cope with inferiority is fantasy; fantasy materializes with scenarios of control, power, and violence, and eventually moves into the real world.
Cognitive & Neurobiological explanation: Escape and control fantasies turning into reality.
Trauma-Focused Developmental Model: Early childhood traumas (violation, abuse, lack of family) pave the way for sadistic tendencies, narcissistic drives, and identity fragmentation.
Cognitive & Neurobiological explanation: Abuse and neglect disrupt emotional development.
Planning–Memory–Decision Processes: Serial killers mentally plan their fantasies; encode crime processes in memory, rehearse them, and optimize their choices with risk–reward evaluation. Memory may be selective and decision-making distorted.
Cognitive & Neurobiological explanation: Internalizing and optimizing crime processes mentally.
Psychopathy and Antisocial Personality: Individuals detached from social norms, lacking empathy and guilt; bright minds, manipulative behaviors, superficial emotions.
Cognitive & Neurobiological explanation: Lack of emotional bond and manipulative structure.
Neuroimaging as a Biological Basis: fMRI, PET, and brain imaging techniques reveal differences in psychopathic and serial killer brain structures (frontal lobe, amygdala, paralimbic system).
References
-
Douglas, J., & Olshaker, M. (2001). The cases that haunt us: From Jack the Ripper to JonBenet Ramsey, the FBI’s legendary mindhunter sheds light on the mysteries that won’t go away. Scribner.
-
Mindhunter: Takeaways From Book Netflix Series Is Based On | TIME
-
How to spot a murderer’s brain | Neuroscience | The Guardian